Unfairly shunned: covert participant observation (2024)

Related Papers

The Generality of the Victim-Offender Overlap: Examining Cultural Contingencies

2014 •

Laurie Gould

View PDF

Dismantling the body, Trafficking the dead- Human remains, organs, and the law of human trafficking

Nicole Siller

An intrinsic and material consequence of mass violence is the mass production of human bodies. Depending on each particular instance of mass atrocity, the fate of these bodies can vary: severe mistreatment, mutilation, concealment, destruction, transport, traffic of the corpses are not uncommon occurrences. Drawing from their respective research on human trafficking and on corpses of mass violence, the co-authors of this paper propose to adopt an intersectional approach and legally examine the issue of the trafficking of human remains and organs as one which is highly revealing of both the criminal modus operandi and the perpetrator’s criminal intent. Yet, international law on the topic is problematically succinct and if the law of human trafficking, as enshrined in the Palermo Protocol (2000), does specify that such trafficking is the deviant obtainment and/or movement of persons for the purpose of exploitation - which does include ‘the removal of organs’ - it however fails to define both the term ‘persons’ and the term ‘organs’. Perhaps leaving the door open for further ambiguity, the Protocol also falls short of expressly contemplating the trafficking of deceased human bodies. How then is an ‘organ’ to be understood? Would it cover bones and human remains? What use have criminals and traffickers made of organs and human remains? Are the perpetrators of the atrocities and the traffickers the same individuals or is there a chain of criminality? What, if any, legal status, protections and/or rights have been given to bodily parts resulting of atrocities and mass violence? By raising and addressing these questions, this paper will highlight the features and characteristics of this very particular type of trafficking and will aim at better grasping the inner criminality of trafficking bodies, whether alive or dead. co-author: Caroline Fournet

View PDF

Meehan, C ‘Legal Highs, Moral Panics And Vigilantism: Lessons From Northern Ireland For New Zealand’ to be presented at European Society of Criminology Annual Conference, September 2014, Prague Czech Republic

This paper is concerned with the long-term impact of media reporting, moral panics and fear of crime on the punishment of drug users in Northern Ireland and the implications for other jurisdictions. Drug use amongst young people, has been widely reported in the media, resulting in two significant moral panics (1994 ecstasy, 2011 mephedrone). Residual mistrust of the criminal justice system in Northern Ireland has catalysed the emergence of paramilitary policing/ vigilantism as a means of dealing with people’s drug use. Failure by state institutions to extinguish paramilitary violence outright has facilitated the reinvention of vigilante organisations as ‘saviours of the community.’ Consequently, their role as a quasi-police force is valorised. Recently there has been similar media reporting and vigilante violence towards retailers selling legal highs in New Zealand. Discussing findings from focus groups and interviews carried out in Northern Ireland and New Zealand, this paper will provide insights from Northern Ireland including the implications of such actions for the drug using community. Keywords: media, moral panics, drugs, fear of crime

View PDF

Varstvoslovje–Journal of Criminal Justice and Security

Slovenian criminology and recent developments in the field of criminal justice and security studies in Slovenia

2008 •

Gorazd Mesko

Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to present the development of criminology and ''criminal justice & security studies''in Slovenia. Design/Methodology/Approach: The paper is based on a literature review and review of a COBISS on-line library using keywords criminology, names of researchers and institutions which provide students with criminology training as well as conduct research in the fields of criminology, criminal law and security studies. Findings:

View PDF

The Politics of Crime and the Financial Crisis in Greece

Sappho Xenakis

View PDF

Collaboration Obstacles and Success: Described and Observed Experiences of Police and Border Guards’ in the Baltic Sea Area

2015 •

Goran Basic

This study analyses the cooperation between police and border guard authorities in the Baltic Sea area and primarily one collaborative project initiated by the Stockholm border police (cofunded by the EU). The purpose of the project is to decrease trans-boundary criminality and improve day-to-day cooperation between police and border officers in the Baltic Sea region. The participants are police and border authorities in Estonia, Finland, Latvia, Lithuania, and Sweden. Earlier research on collaboration shows that cooperation comprises problems and conflicts. The purpose of this study is to map and analyze how the staff of the different organizations experience, understand, and define obstacles of cooperation as well as successful cooperation, and which interactive and discursive patterns are involved in the construction of this phenomenon. The empirical basis for this study are qualitative interviews and field observations of organized intelligence and operational meetings and infor...

View PDF

Effects of question order on the assessment of police performance

2015 •

Georges Steffgen

View PDF

Challenges of Slovenian criminology

2002 •

Dragan Petrovec

An important part of research in general is aimed at influencing the phenomena of its analysis. This holds especially true of applied research. By doing this, the research activity takes over a very important role since it indirectly takes some responsibility for development of the researched area in everyday life. This holds particularly true of the research of crime and of crime policy based upon its results. This contribution tries to present some criminological research projects carried out in Slovenia as well as their possible influence ...

View PDF

Key Issues in Criminology: JANUS III

Janice Pace

View PDF

Eurocrim 2017 Cardiff

A framework to trace the changing conceptualization of crime through history

2017 •

Iris Steenhout

View PDF
Unfairly shunned: covert participant observation (2024)

FAQs

What are the ethical issues with covert participant observation? ›

However, a disadvantage of covert observation is that it raises a number of ethical concerns. If people are unaware that they are the objects of sociological study, they have not given informed consent. It might be possible, in some cases, to get consent after the study has taken place, or to receive general consent.

What is one of the ethical problems with covert participant observation _________? ›

One of the ethical problems with covert participant observation such as Laud Humphreys study of male hom*osexual sex in public bathrooms is: subjecting the participants to physical harm. observing people outside of their natural setting. violating the privacy of his subjects.

What is an example of a covert participant observation? ›

An example is the research for A Glasgow Gang Observed. A 26-year-old schoolmaster at a Scottish Reformatory (ListD) school, who called himself James Patrick, went undercover with the help of one of his pupils to study the often violent behaviour of the teenagers in a gang in Glasgow.

What are the limitations of covert observations? ›

While informed consent is not necessary in some cases, many view it as ethical protection for the individuals involved. Since those being observed covertly are unaware that they are being studied, they can not provide their informed consent, which makes this research method ethically questionable.

What are the ethical weaknesses of participant observation? ›

Disadvantages cont.

Risk of researchers 'going native', that is, becoming so involved that they lose objectivity. Only a small group is studied, so may not be representative. Covert participant observation is ethically unsound.

How to make covert observation ethical? ›

However, it is crucial for the researcher to consider ethical considerations and privacy concerns when using such recording devices. They must ensure that the participants' identities and personal information are protected, and that the observations are used solely for research purposes.

What is the most ethically concerning role in participant observation is overt participant? ›

The researcher may still participate in the activity being observed (overt participant observation) or might play no part and simply observe (overt non-participant observation). This is the most ethical form of observation, as it requires no deception and participants are able to give their informed consent.

What do the guidelines say about covert observational research? ›

Current Guidance

The broad principle should be that covert research must not be undertaken lightly or routinely. It is only justified if important issues are being addressed and if matters of social significance which cannot be uncovered in other ways are likely to be discovered.

What are the ethical issues of observation? ›

Privacy, Confidentiality, and Anonymity

It was implied earlier that lack of informed consent in shadowing may sometimes be implicit, and thus the respect for participant privacy lies in the hands of a researcher committed to ethical decision-making when faced with such dilemmas.

Is covert participant observation valid? ›

It's also unlikely a researcher will be able to generalise their findings from one study to the next (for example, is Goffman's study of a mental asylum applicable to all mental institutions?). Participant observation (whether overt or covert) is not the most reliable research method.

What are 3 examples of covert behavior? ›

Examples of overt behaviour include running, dancing, arguing, smiling, frowning, etc. Whereas examples of covert behaviour include thinking, dreaming, glandular responses, etc.

What is a famous covert observation? ›

Examples include Laud Humphries's covert observations of hom*osexual encounters (Tearoom Trade, 1970), and work by Leon Festinger and his colleagues, who observed a religious cult by pretending to become adherents to its beliefs (When Prophecy Fails, 1956).

What is one of the ethical problems with covert participant observation? ›

Covert observations raise ethical concerns around informed consent, privacy, and potential harm to participants. Covert observations, where the subjects are unaware they are being observed, can be a valuable tool in psychological research. However, they also raise significant ethical issues.

Which of the following is a drawback of covert observation? ›

Covert observation would not be helpful because students are being deceived as they didn't give their consent to the research and they may have to break the law to maintain cover.

Why is covert research problematic? ›

The covert nature of the research involves the intentional deception of participants, which is ethically problematic. Deception can lead to a breach of trust between the researcher and the subjects.

What are the ethical issues with covert surveillance? ›

The main ethical implications of covert surveillance include invasion of privacy, violation of human rights, and potential abuse of power.

What are the ethical issues of Asch's research? ›

Finally, Asch's research is ethically questionable. He broke several ethical guidelines, including: deception and protection from harm. Asch deliberately deceived his participants, saying that they were taking part in a vision test and not an experiment on conformity.

What are the theoretical issues with participant observation? ›

Because participant observation involves the researcher immersing themselves in the group being studied, there is a risk that their own biases could influence the data they collect, leading to observer bias.

References

Top Articles
Baldur's Gate 3: release date, classes, and everything else we know
Baldurs Gate 3: Komplettlösung, Guides, Tipps und Tricks
The Shoppes At Zion Directory
Watch After Ever Happy 123Movies
Csuf Mail
Brett Cooper Wikifeet
LOVEBIRDS - Fly Babies Aviary
2167+ Unique Pieces of Authentic Mid Century Modern Furniture In Stock - furniture - by dealer - sale - craigslist
Costco Fuel Price Today Near Me
Rick Lee Oaklawn Park Picks Today
Nycers Pay Schedule
Henry Ford Hospital: Ein Meisterwerk von Frida Kahlo
7 Best Character Builds In Nioh 2
R Umineko
Chubbs Canton Il
Lowell Holiday Wrestling Tournament 2022
Almost Home Natchitoches Menu
Craiglist Tulsa Ok
Tractorhouse Farm Equipment
Vector Driver Setup
Katonah Train Times
Amazing Lash Bay Colony
Ice Dodo Unblocked 76
James And Lisa Goy Obituary
Offres Emploi Purchasing manager Paris (75000) | HelloWork
Kentucky Lottery Scratch Offs Remaining
Mighty B Wcostream
Identogo Roanoke Va
Wirrig Pavilion Seating Chart
Disney Cruise Line
Webmail.unt.edu
Clash of Clans: Best Hero Equipment For The Archer Queen, Ranked
Age Gabriela Moura's Evolution from Childhood Dreams to TikTok Fame - Essential Tribune
Palmer Santin Funeral Home Fullerton Nebraska Obituaries
4 Pics One Word Level 363
They Cloned Tyrone Showtimes Near Showbiz Cinemas - Kingwood
Visit Lake Oswego! - Lake Oswego Chamber Of Commerce
Rugrats in Paris: The Movie | Rotten Tomatoes
Hawkview Retreat Pa Cost
Helas Kitchen Menu
Below Her Mouth | Rotten Tomatoes
Chihuahua Adoption in Las Vegas, NV: Chihuahua Puppies for Sale in Las Vegas, NV - Adoptapet.com
charleston rooms & shares - craigslist
Enterprise Car Sales Jacksonville Used Cars
5Gomovies
Bbc Weather In Mallorca
Waylon Jennings - Songs, Children & Death
Dollar Tree Aktie (DLTR) • US2567461080
Oriellys Tooele
Slug Menace Rs3
Rubrankings Austin
Kaiju Universe: Best Monster Tier List (January 2024) - Item Level Gaming
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Fredrick Kertzmann

Last Updated:

Views: 5811

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (46 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Fredrick Kertzmann

Birthday: 2000-04-29

Address: Apt. 203 613 Huels Gateway, Ralphtown, LA 40204

Phone: +2135150832870

Job: Regional Design Producer

Hobby: Nordic skating, Lacemaking, Mountain biking, Rowing, Gardening, Water sports, role-playing games

Introduction: My name is Fredrick Kertzmann, I am a gleaming, encouraging, inexpensive, thankful, tender, quaint, precious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.